REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT
NAIROBI
(O N Makau J on 12th November 2026)
CAUSE NO. 886 OF 2018
JOSEPH KENG’ARA ONGUSO ………..…………………………….... CLAIMANT
VERSUS
SANA INDUSTRIES COMPANY LTD …………….…................. RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
Introduction
1. At all material times to this suit, the claimant was employed by the respondent and his last day at work was 15th June 2016. By a Memorandum of Claim dated 25th May 2018, the claimant sued the respondent for unfair and unlawful summary dismissal and sought the following reliefs:
a) One month salary in lieu of notice…………………………Kshs.12,143
b) Salary for the month of April 2016……………………..….Kshs.12,143
c) Unpaid leave days (Kshs.12,143 x 6 years………………Kshs.72,858
d) Service pay (15/30 x 6 x Kshs.12,143)…………………….Kshs.36,429
e) Maximum compensation or as may be ordered
by this honourable court…………………………………..….Kshs.145,716
Total………………………………………………..…….Kshs.279,289
f) Certificate of service
g) Cost of this suit.
2. The respondent admitted that it had employed the claimant as a general worker but denied the alleged summary dismissal and the reliefs sought. It averred that it suspended the claimant for 14 days from 15th June 2018 but failed to report back as required. It further averred that the claimant deserted his employment after the lapse of the suspension and therefore the suit ought to be dismissed with costs for lack of merits.
Claimant’s Case
3. The claimant testified as CW1 and adopted his statement dated 18th May 2018 as his evidence in chief. He also produced a demand letter dated 9th May 2017 and a bundle of his payslips as exhibits to support his case.
4. In brief, his case was that he was employed by the respondent as a Machine Operator for a monthly salary of Kshs.12,143. In June 2016, while in the course of his duties of sealing a package of hair, he asked in Swahili, “hii ni karatasi gani?” (what kind of paper is this?).
5. The above question provoked the security guard on duty to beat him telling him that he was making noise. He was then escorted by the guard to the office where the Manager told him to record a statement. After recording the statement, the Manager dismissed him from employment. He never received any letter from the employer asking him to report back to work or attend disciplinary hearing.
6. On cross examination, he admitted that whenever his leave matured, he was told to go. However, on two occasions he applied for the leave and it was declined.
7. He further admitted that he was paid his salary for April and May 2016 plus the days he worked in June 2016. He also admitted that the employer contributed National Social Security Fund for him.
8. He admitted that the attendance register for 15th and 16th June 2016 showed that he was on suspension which is different from termination. He denied that he was suspended and maintained that he was dismissed on the spot by the Manager after recording a statement.
9. He confirmed that the allegation made against him was that he was making noise and causing disturbance but maintained that he was only enquiring about the new sealing paper. He admitted that his written statement never mentioned that he was assaulted by a security guard but contended that he just forgot to do so.
10. He admitted that he never reported the assault to the police or the OSHS and he never went to any hospital for treatment.
11. On being shown letters written by Dennis Njagi and Julius Ondieki, he confirmed and stated that he was suspended for making noise. However, he denied receipt of the show cause letter dated 14th July 2016; letter dated 30th June 2016 calling him back to work; letter writing him to a disciplinary hearing and the dismissal letter.
12. On re-examination, he maintained that he was dismissed on the spot in June 2016. He reiterated that he recorded a statement of the assault by the security guard and left it with the Manager in the office.
Defence Case
13. The respondent called its Human Resource Manager, Ms. Agnes Kagwiria who testified as RW1. She adopted her statement dated 2nd November 2020 as her evidence in chief and produced 6 documents as exhibits.
14. In brief, her case was that the claimant was employed by the respondent as a general worker from 2013 to 2016 when he deserted his employment. She explained that on 15th June 2016, the claimant was found idling and making noise at the place of work and he was directed to concentrate in his work and stop distracting his colleagues. The claimant ignored the directive and he was summoned by his supervisor and asked why he was disrupting other employees from doing their work, but he refused to respond.
15. As a result of the foregoing matters, the supervisor referred the claimant to the Human Resource Office where he was questioned about the said conduct and again he refused to answer. Consequently, the respondent suspended him for two weeks and instructed him to report back on 29th June 2016.
16. After the lapse of the suspension period, the claimant never reported back to work even after being served with a letter calling him back to work and cautioning him that desertion of duty amounted to gross misconduct. He further ignored a letter inviting him to a disciplinary hearing. Consequently, the respondent paid him salary for the days worked and pro-rata leave earned.
17. She denied the reliefs sought by the claimant contending that the claimant voluntarily deserted his employment. She contended that the prayer for service pay was not merited since the respondent contributed NSSF for the claimant. Finally, she contended that the claimant’s certificate is available for him to collect upon clearance with the respondent.
18. On cross examination, she contended that she served the claimant with all the said letters through the Shop steward at the shop floor because the claimant was a member of the Kenya Union of Hari and Beauty Workers (KUHABWO). However, she admitted that she had no evidence that the claimant received the said letters. She also admitted that the letters did not bear any address for the claimant. She admitted that she was not present when the claimant was allegedly disturbing other workers in the factory, but she was told by the security officers.
19. She relied on two letters/statements written by Dennis Njagi and Julius Ondieki. She admitted that the letter by Ondieki did not indicate his name on it and the date was illegible. She stated that Dennis Njagi was dead while Julius Ondieki was no longer working for the respondent. She admitted that Ondieki never stated that the claimant was idling and making noise.
20. She maintained that the claimant was not dismissed but only suspended. She contended that he was brought to her by the Factory Manager for questioning but he refused to record a statement and she suspended him. She admitted that Dennis Njagi was not present when she questioned the claimant. No Minutes were recorded for the meeting.
21. She further admitted that Dennis Njagi and Julius Ondieki recorded their statements/letters two years after the incidence. They recorded the statements/letters in her office.
22. As regards to the length of service by the claimant, she contended that he worked from 2013 to 2016 as a general work. However, she did not produce the contract of employment or other employment records of the claimant as exhibits. She explained the protocol when an employee had issues, thus, the employee is first taken to the factory supervisor, then to the Manager and then to the Human Resource Officer for disciplinary action. She contended that Julius Ondieki was in her office when the claimant was brought there by Dennis Njagi. She maintained that she never dismissed the claimant but merely suspended him but later he absconded. She admitted that suspension is done by issuing a document.
23. After the close of the hearing, both sides filed written submissions. Having considered the pleadings, evidence and the submissions presented, there is no doubt that the parties herein engaged in a contract of employment and the last date when the claimant attended work was 15th June 2016. The following issues fall for determination:
a) Whether the claimant was summarily dismissed on 15th June 2016 or he willfully deserted employment on 29th June 2016.
b) If the answer to (a) above is dismissal, whether the same was unfair and unlawful.
c) Whether the claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.
Dismissal Versus Desertion
24. The success or failure of this suit depends on the answer to this question. The claimant contended that on the material date, he enquired about the type of the new sealing paper and then the security guard assaulted him alleging that he was making noise and distracting other employees. Immediately, he was taken to the Manager who asked him to record a statement about the incident and he complied. No sooner had he finished recording the statement than the Manager dismissed him on the spot without any prior notice, hearing or valid reason. Thereafter, he never received any letter from the employer but his salary for days worked in June 2016 was paid.
25. The respondent’s case on the other hand, was that the claimant was found idling and making noise in the factory, and thereby distracting other employees. He was then taken to the RW1’s office for questioning after he failed to co-operate with the other levels in the company disciplinary protocols. She contended that Julius Ondieki was in her office when the claimant was brought to her by Dennis Njagi. When she questioned the claimant about the alleged misconduct, he refused to respond and suspended him for two weeks and directed him to report back on 29th June 2016 but he deserted. She wrote to him a letter requiring him to report back to work, followed by a show cause letter, and an invitation to hearing but he ignored all of them. Consequently, she wrote a summary dismissal letter dated 2nd September 2016. All the said letters were allegedly served through the Union Shop Steward because the claimant was a member of KUHABWO.
26. I have carefully considered the evidence on record. The claimant stated that he was dismissed on the spot for alleged noise making at the factory and distracting other workers. He denied both the offence and the allegation that he was suspended for two weeks. I find this explanation weighty and capable of shifting the burden of proof to the respondent to prove that it never dismissed the claimant but rather suspended him.
27. RW1 admitted that there were no Minutes recorded for the meeting with the claimant on the material date. She further admitted that suspension is done by a document but she did not produce a copy of the suspension letter/document to buttress her allegation and rebut the alleged dismissal.
28. She also admitted that all the letters she wrote to the claimant after the alleged suspension did not indicate his address, and that she had no proof that they reached the claimant. She also never called the alleged Shop Steward to confirm to this Court that he delivered the letters to the claimant. Instead, the respondent filed two letters signed by Dennis Njagi and Julius Ondieki written two years after the incidence. The said letters do not state that the authors were present when RW1 issued the claimant with suspension note.
29. Having taken all the facts and observations above into account, I find that the respondent’s evidence has gaps which renders it not capable of rebutting the claimant’s case. RW1 admitted that suspension is done by a document but she did not adduce any as evidence. She also wrote letters to found a case of desertion of employment but they failed to serve the same and went ahead to dismiss the claimant vide a letter dated 2nd September 2016 which was also not served upon the claimant.
30. In the circumstances of this case, I hold that the claimant has proved on a balance of probability that he was summarily dismissed by the respondent on 15th June 2016. He was removed from his work place by a security guard and escorted to RW1 who verbally ordered him to leave the company premises before time. Had the RW1 suspended him, she would have given him a suspension note stating clearly the date for reporting back for the same reasons. I am not satisfied that the claimant deserted employment as alleged by the respondent.
Unfair and Unlawful Termination
31. Section 45(2) of the Employment Act provides:
“(2)A termination of employment by an employer is unfair if the employer fails to prove—
(a) that the reason for the termination is valid;
(b) that the reason for the termination is a fair reason—
(i) related to the employees conduct, capacity
or compatibility; or
(ii) based on the operational requirements of
the employer; and
that the employment was terminated in accordance with fair procedure.”
32. The above provision sets out two factors that determine whether the termination of employment is unfair or not, namely substantive fairness and procedural fairness. The former refers to the validity of the reason for the termination while the latter refers to fair opportunities accorded to an employee to defend himself/herself before termination of employment.
Reason for termination
33. The claimant contended that he was dismissed for alleged noise making and disturbing other employees in the factory. However, he denied the offence and stated that he only enquired about the type of the new sealing paper he was given to use in his work. No employee recorded any statement to the effect that the claimant’s question was disturbing or distracting him. The factory supervisor never recorded statement or testified in this case to support the said allegation that the claimant was distracting other workers. In the circumstance, I find that allegations by the security guard that the claimant was making noise and disturbing other workers to be unfounded.
Procedural fairness
34. Even if the reason for the termination was valid, which has not been proved, the dismissal would still be rendered unfair by the failure by the respondent to follow due process. Section 41 of the Employment Act provides that:
“(1) Subject to section 42(1), an employer shall, before terminating the employment of an employee, on the grounds of misconduct, poor performance or physical incapacity explain to the employee, in a language the employee understands, the reason for which the employer is considering termination and the employee shall be entitled to have another employee or a shop floor union representative of his choice present during this explanation.
(2) Notwithstanding any other provision of this Part, an employer shall, before terminating the employment of an employee or summarily dismissing an employee under section 44(3) hear and consider any representations which the employee may on the grounds of misconduct or poor performance, and the person, if any, chosen by the employee within subsection (1), make.”
35. The respondent did not prove that it followed the above mandatory procedure before dismissing the claimant. RW1 admitted that the claimant was brought to her for questioning and disciplinary action. She explained the protocol for disciplinary cases which ends in her office for disciplinary action. Taking into account all the facts of the case, I find that the respondent has failed to prove that it followed a fair procedure before dismissing the claimant for noise making at the factory and that rendered the summary dismissal unfair and unlawful within the meaning of section 45 of the Employment Act.
Reliefs
36. In view of the foregoing conclusion, I find that the claimant is entitled to reliefs under Section 49 of the Employment Act. He prayed for salary in lieu of notice and compensation for unfair termination. He prayed for one month salary in lieu of notice plus 12 months’ salary as compensation for unfair termination.
37. I award him one month salary in lieu of notice under Section 35(1) (c) of the Employment Act which provides for a notice of 28 days for an employee whose salary is based on monthly intervals. He will get Kshs.12,143 as prayed.
38. As regards compensation for unfair termination, I have considered his period of service from 2013 to 2016, about three (3) years and also the fact that no misconduct was proved against him or any warning letter produced to show that he had previous record of misconduct or poor performance. Consequently, I award him six (6) months’ salary as compensation for unfair termination. Hence Kshs.12,143 x 6 = Kshs.145,716.
39. The claimant further prayed for leave for six years but during cross examination, he admitted that he was being told to go whenever his leaves matured. He further stated that only on two occasions he applied for the leave and it was denied. However, he never gave any particulars of the denied leave. Consequently, the claim for leave is declined.
40. Likewise, the claim for service pay is declined because the claimant produced payslips showing that he was a contributing member of the NSSF.
41. The claimant for certificate of service is merited pursuant to Section 51 of the Employment Act. Therefore, I order the respondent to issue one to the claimant forthwith.
Conclusion
42. I have found that the summary dismissal of the claimant on 15th June 2016 was unfair and unlawful. I have further found that he is entitled to remedy under Section 49 and 51 of the Employment Act. Consequently, I enter judgment for the claimant against the respondent as follows:
a) Notice…………………………………………………..Kshs.12,143.00
b) Compensation……………………………………Kshs.145,716.00
Total………………………………………Kshs.157,859.00
c) The award is subject to statutory deduction.
d) Claimant is awarded costs plus interest at court rate from the date of the judgment.
DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 12TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026.
ONESMUS MAKAU
JUDGE
Appearance:
Njiru for Nyakwana for Claimant
Popela for Respondent